Bug #3615: /etc/rc.d/*.sh start" is executed during bootup, but equivalent "stop" cmd is never issued during shutdown - pfSense - pfSense bugtracker

Actions

Copy link

Bug #3615

closed

/etc/rc.d/*.sh start" is executed during bootup, but equivalent "stop" cmd is never issued during shutdown

Added by Dreamcat Four almost 10 years ago. Updated almost 10 years ago.

Status:

Closed

Priority:

Normal

Assignee:

Category:

Operating System

Target version:

2.2

Start date:

04/22/2014

Due date:

% Done:

Estimated time:

Plus Target Version:

Release Notes:

Affected Version:

Affected Architecture:

Description

Hi there. I apologize if this is issue has been entered in the wrong category.

There seems to be no feature to allow a user to run their rc scripts at shutdown. (non-packages). To gracefully stop a service and release it's resources back.

For example: I would like to use the 3rd method documented in this page, where an rc.d script is renamed with an ".sh" extension:

https://doc.pfsense.org/index.php/Executing_commands_at_boot_time

This seems to be processed by "/etc/rc.start_packages" - and will exec "/etc/rc.d/*.sh start" for each file found. However "/etc/rc.stop_packages" seems to have some issue. The code looks like it trys to do something similar. But the code isn't quite the same and it fails to run "/etc/rc.d/*.sh stop". Can we please fix this somehow ?

Other popular nanoBSD platforms (FreeNAS and NAS4Free) provide a GUI page where users can specify their own list of "POSTINIT" and "SHUTDOWN" scripts. It isn't hidden away or anything.

But if you guys could get pfSense to just auto-run "/etc/rc.d/*.sh stop" from your "/etc/rc.stop_packages" (in 2.2 onwards). Then that would work great for me.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Dreamcat Four almost 10 years ago

Reading carefully the official FreeBSD manages, the behaviour of this feature is ambiguous.

If you `man rc`, where it says:

Operation of rc.shutdown

4.   Call each script in turn using run_rc_script() (from rc.subr(8)),
          which sets $1 to ``stop'', and sources the script in a subshell.  If
          the script has a .sh suffix then it is sourced directly into the
          current shell.

I don't recommend anyone should be using it. Because it is ambiguous whether sourcing on shutdown with or without "$1" ("stop") argument parameter. I have already seen other people on pfSense forums using these .sh scripts at startup, perhaps disregarding the start function entirely.

Instead of polluting the existing rc.d folder for such customisations, those who can't make a proper package would be better of creating the file "/etc/rc.custom_boot_early". If found, will be executed during boot up. For multiple script, people can reference them now-by-line in there.

For stopping services, you (ESF) will need to submit a pull request for a similar (counterpart) shutdown hook. I'll raise a new separate issue for that.

Actions

Copy link