Bug #10553
closed
Gateway Groups Tier 2 fail dropping states on Tier 1 connection
Added by Daniel Subert almost 4 years ago.
Updated almost 4 years ago.
Category:
Gateway Monitoring
Affected Version:
2.4.4-p3
Description
Symptom:
State drops occurring incorrectly in certain fail-over conditions
Setup:
Gateway Group with 2 gateways setup in tiers:
WAN1 = Tier 1
WAN2 = Tier 2
Online status change on WAN2 causes state drop of WAN1 states
To recreate the bug:
- 1. Establish a state over WAN1 (HTTP/SSH/RDP etc)
- 2. Introduce packet loss or disconnect WAN2
- (dpinger may also log that packet loss is occuring on WAN1!)
- 3. States on WAN1 will drop
Notes:
Where a status change (up/down/packet loss/etc) on WAN1 occurs, states on WAN2 are unaffected.
- Category set to Gateway Monitoring
- Status changed from New to Not a Bug
That's the expected behavior currently. There is no way to have it only kill states for connections on a specific WAN/gateway.
There is already a request to enhance that open at #8555
Hi Jim,
Is dpinger aware of the gateway groups tiers?
The states should only be dropped if the active tier is down. For example:
- If Tier 1 and Tier 2 is up, all states will be on the Tier 1 gateway.
- If Tier 2 gateway then fails, there are no states on the Tier 2 gateway to drop, so there should be no action.
Thus dpinger could be told that if the tier with the failure is not the current tier, do nothing.
Possibly overlooked is the fact that dpinger has marked WAN1 on Tier 1 as packet loss / down when WAN2 has issues. In our testing WAN1 definitely does not have any packet loss or connectivity issue despite dpingers report to the contrary.
Please consider reviewing support ticket 51437, the support team advised us to register a bug report for the behavior we are observing.
I'm very confident that there is some unintended behavior here.
Also available in: Atom
PDF
Updated by 
Updated by