Bug #2278: IPv6 Carp vip both master on FreeBSD 8.3 - pfSense - pfSense bugtracker

Actions

Copy link

Bug #2278

closed

IPv6 Carp vip both master on FreeBSD 8.3

Added by Seth Mos almost 13 years ago. Updated over 12 years ago.

Status:

Resolved

Priority:

High

Assignee:

Category:

CARP

Target version:

2.1

Start date:

03/12/2012

Due date:

% Done:

Estimated time:

Plus Target Version:

Release Notes:

Affected Version:

2.1-IPv6

Affected Architecture:

Description

On our FreeBSD 8.3 snapshots both carp members will become master for IPv6 vips. The IPv4 vips if they exist work normally and stay backup on the backup member.

This worked with the same configuration on our FreeBSD 8.1 snapshots.

Files

Download all files

carp-a-8.3.pcap (5.54 KB) carp-a-8.3.pcap	carp a on 8.3	Seth Mos, 03/12/2012 05:11 AM
carp-b-8.3.pcap (6.42 KB) carp-b-8.3.pcap	carp b on 8.3	Seth Mos, 03/12/2012 05:11 AM
carp-a-8.3-b-8.1.pcap (5.97 KB) carp-a-8.3-b-8.1.pcap	carp a on 8.3 and b on 8.1	Seth Mos, 03/12/2012 05:11 AM
carp-b-8.1.pcap (5.97 KB) carp-b-8.1.pcap	carp b on 8.3	Seth Mos, 03/12/2012 05:11 AM
carp-a-8.1-b-8.1.pcap (6 KB) carp-a-8.1-b-8.1.pcap	carp a on 8.1 and b on 8.1	Seth Mos, 03/12/2012 05:11 AM

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Seth Mos almost 13 years ago

File carp-a-8.3.pcap carp-a-8.3.pcap added
File carp-b-8.3.pcap carp-b-8.3.pcap added
File carp-a-8.3-b-8.1.pcap carp-a-8.3-b-8.1.pcap added
File carp-b-8.1.pcap carp-b-8.1.pcap added
File carp-a-8.1-b-8.1.pcap carp-a-8.1-b-8.1.pcap added

I have attached 4 pcaps. The 1st 2 pcap files are both members running 8.3.

Pcap 3 and 4 is the master and backup node running a 8.1 snapshots from http://files.pfsense.org/jimp/ipv6/
I'm using pfSense-Full-Update-2.1-DEVELOPMENT-i386-20111125-1741.tgz as this was the last "good" 8.1 snap.

As soon as the backup node is downgraded to a 8.1 snapshot it kicks into backup again.

The other way around makes no difference, if the primary is 8.1 and the backup is 8.3 they both will be master.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Seth Mos almost 13 years ago

Assignee set to Ermal Luçi

Just tested with 2 clean FreeBSD 8.3-RC1 vms and there the IPv6 Carp backup and failover works correctly. That implies that it is related to our patches for 8.3.

Ermal can you debug this with the information provided here?

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Chris Buechler almost 13 years ago

Target version changed from 8 to 2.1
Affected Version changed from 2.1 to 2.1-IPv6

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Ermal Luçi almost 13 years ago

Probably it will be related to the IPv6 patch there is in there.
Can you confirm that Seth?

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Seth Mos over 12 years ago

Status changed from New to Feedback

~~Can not replicate with FreeBSD 8.3-RC2 snapshots from snapshots.pfsense.org. Possibly fixed between RC1 and RC2.~~

~~Possibly others can confirm.~~

Scratch that, the primary, which was RC1 still, was up for 46 days but seized all IPv6 comms to the vips. Even rebooting the master and backup did not allow comms to restore.
After downgrading to 8.1 snaps from Jim made on 25th november 2011 it all came back to live.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Chris Buechler over 12 years ago

Status changed from Feedback to New

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Pierre BLONDEAU over 12 years ago

I have a similar problem on 2.1-DEVELOPMENT (i386) built on Tue Apr 10 21:11:54 EDT 2012.

13 IPv4 carp OK
3 IPv6 are Master on both server.

Regards

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Seth Mos over 12 years ago

The last good snapshot is from http://files.pfsense.org/jimp/ipv6/

I'm still running the snapshots from Nov 25th on 3 carp clusters.

Another issue that I've managed to reproduce on another carp cluster is that FreeBSD 8.3 will stop responding to Neighbor Discovery requests and thus the CARP vips will wall from the internet, so if you have a static route pointing at a carp vip everything behind it, it will become unreachable.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Pierre BLONDEAU over 12 years ago

I have this problem, but only on one of my carp ipv6 addresses and only a few machines (not all).
I thought it was from my configuration, but it appears to be identical.

Actions

Copy link

#10

Updated by Seth Mos over 12 years ago

Can you check if the CARP vip address is in the NDP table of any of the other machines?

On linux http://tldp.org/HOWTO/Linux+IPv6-HOWTO/x1162.html

# ip -6 neigh show

That should show the CARP IPv6 vip in there.
On FreeBSD

#ndp -a

if the IPv6 CARP vips do not show in the clients or servers then it means that FreeBSD is not responding to ND requests.

Actions

Copy link

#11

Updated by Pierre BLONDEAU over 12 years ago

on the one where it works :
ip -6 neigh show
2001:xxx:yyy::1 dev eth0 lladdr 00:00:5e:xx:xx:xx router DELAY
on the other :
ip -6 neigh show
2001:xxx:yyy::1 dev eth0 FAILED
I have 10 / 36 machines which can't join the router CARP Ipv6 ( All linux debian squeeze up to date).

Actions

Copy link

#12

Updated by Pierre BLONDEAU over 12 years ago

I have found the difference, it's the uptime of client. If I restart them all, IPv6 will not work on them.

Actions

Copy link

#13

Updated by Seth Mos over 12 years ago

Jim found a very descriptive similar issue on Open that appears to hit the exact same thing.
http://old.nabble.com/carp-ipv6-ndp-issue-td32201650.html

Actions

Copy link

#14